What size should I order?Updated 16 days ago

Men's Boots - Our boots are designed with a generous fit, which typically results in a larger overall volume and length compared to standard US sizing. To ensure the most comfortable and accurate fit, we strongly recommend ordering half a size smaller than your typical US shoe size. For instance, if your average US shoe size across various brands and styles is a 10D (regular width), we advise selecting a 9.5D in any of our boots. 

If you own other Goodyear-welted footwear that fits you well, you can generally order the same size in our boots with confidence. For instance, if your average US Goodyear-welted boot size across various brands and styles is a 10D (regular width), we advise selecting a 10D in any of our boots.

For our Men's Chelsea boots, we offer them in D and EE widths.

Men's Shoes - For our Plain Toe Bluchers, Moc Toe Derbies, and Bucks, we recommend ordering half a size smaller than your typical US shoe size. Alternatively, if you are familiar with your sizing in Goodyear-welted footwear from other brands, you can confidently order the same size. For instance, if you typically wear a size 10D in most US shoe brands or 9.5D in your average Goodyear-welted footwear, we suggest opting for a 9.5D.

In contrast, our Cap Toe Oxfords, Fairfield Oxfords, and Coast Sneakers are designed to fit true to your standard US shoe size. Therefore, we advise ordering the same size you typically wear in other US shoe brands.

Men's Loafers - For our Traveler Penny and Tassel loafers, we recommend ordering half a size smaller than your typical US shoe size. Alternatively, if you are familiar with your sizing in Goodyear-welted footwear from other brands, you can confidently order the same size. For instance, if you typically wear a size 10D in most US shoe brands or 9.5D in your average Goodyear-welted footwear, we suggest opting for a 9.5D.

In contrast, our Horsebit loafers are designed to fit true to your standard US shoe size. Therefore, we advise ordering the same size you typically wear in other US shoe brands.

See all of our lasts and fitting information here. 

Women's Footwear - Our women’s footwear is designed to fit true to your standard US shoe size. For example, if your average US shoe size is a 7, then a 7 in our women’s loafers and boots will likely provide the most comfortable fit.

Please list some of your favorite brands and sizes for a specific recommendation, and email us with those details. Suppose you'd like to try a couple of sizes side by side. In that case, you can order two items and return whichever you prefer (customers shipping outside the US are encouraged to contact us in advance for sizing assistance). *Items returned will incur a restocking fee.*

If you have received an order and would like guidance or feedback, we are happy to help. Please provide a photo of your laced boots or shoes on your feet while wearing appropriate socks. This will allow us to evaluate the spacing and understand your experience.

When taking the photo:

• Ensure your heel is fully back in the footwear and the laces are snug.

• Take a photo from directly above (birds-eye view).

• Mark the photo to indicate the widest part of your foot and the end of your toes.

In addition to the photo, please also describe:

• The height of your instep (high, moderate, or low).

• Indicate whether the widest part of your foot aligns with the widest part of the boot/shoe. If not, indicate whether it is in front of or behind.

• Any additional feedback is welcome.